Recently, Vice President Kamala Harris offered Black voters a familiar piece of advice: be transactional. In plain terms, she suggested Black votes should function as currency, a demand for something specific in exchange for electoral support. On its surface, that sounds like hard-nosed pragmatism, a call to stop giving away political power for free.
But for a people whose history in America is a long, brutal chronicle of a rigged marketplace, transaction alone is not enough. Black voters cannot afford to reject transactional politics outright. We need resources, policy commitments, appointments, protections, and measurable gains. But we also cannot mistake a transaction for transformation. The question is not whether Black voters should be transactional. The question is whether each transaction builds the power necessary to transform the conditions under which the next transaction happens.
Dr. Amanda Wilkerson
That distinction matters and a conversation without a discussion of both fails in application. Here is why, a transaction assumes a fair market: two parties exchanging goods of equal value under mutually agreed-upon terms. That has never been the political environment in which Black people have operated. Enslaved Africans could not negotiate their way out of bondage. There was no fair deal to be struck with a system that defined them as property and counted them as fractions of human beings. No concession from a slaveholder could transform the fundamental evil of owning another person. Freedom required abolition. Abolition was not a transaction. It was a transformation of law, labor, citizenship, and moral possibility.
Jim Crow told the same story in different clothes. Could Black people have negotiated for a slightly better seat on the segregated bus? A marginally better-funded segregated school? Perhaps. That would have been the transactional approach: an exchange of political quiet for a modest improvement in our subordinate status. But a marginally improved subordinate status is still subordinate. The Civil Rights Movement was not built merely on better terms within segregation. It demanded the destruction of segregation itself.
This
Dr. Valerie Wilkerson
That is the work, transacting to transform.













