"We believed that we would be here."
That's how Caroline Goulet, president of the University of Providence in Great Falls, Montana, explained why the university recruited this year's athletes even as it ran out of money. On Oct. 27, Providence's trustees voted to close the university after the 2026-27 academic year. Its 15 teams will finish their seasons. Then, the school will be gone.
Providence is small, with about 630 students. But 312 of them are athletes, out of 397 students on campus, according to The Electric, a local news outlet. Providence didn't just have an athletics program. In a real sense, it was one.
It isn't alone. Lourdes University in Ohio announced its closure earlier this year. Athletes were 72% of its undergraduates in 2023-24, according to federal data analyzed by sport management professor Steve Dittmore. The Chronicle of Higher Education reported that Lourdes' athletes received an average tuition discount of 74%, compared with about 34% for other students. And after the 2024-25 season, Concordia University Ann Arbor, where roughly 80% of students were athletes, stopped sponsoring sports altogether.
These aren't isolated stories. The Chronicle found that more than 80% of private colleges with 500 to 3,000 students added athletes between 2012 and 2022, and the median share of undergraduates who were athletes rose from 21% to nearly a third. Yet 56% of those colleges lost undergraduate enrollment over the same period.
Read that again. Most of these colleges were adding athletes and still shrinking. The roster was growing while the rest of the campus emptied out around it. At some point, a college that is mostly a team stops being a college with a team, and it inherits every risk that comes with that, from injuries to coaching turnover to the next conference shake-up. Its students inherit those risks, too, usually without anyone telling them.
I understand why small colleges made the bet. Athletes enroll, they stay, and they bring their friends and families to campus. For many young people, especially those who never expected to play beyond high school, a roster spot at a small college is a door to a degree that might otherwise have stayed closed. That's a good thing, and it's worth protecting.
But when a college builds its enrollment on athletes, it takes on an obligation to them, and the obligation doesn't end when the money does. Right now, closure planning in higher education focuses on academics, as it should: teach-out agreements, transcripts, credit transfers. Athletics is an afterthought. An athlete at a closing college faces questions no transcript answers. Will I lose a season of eligibility if I transfer? Will my next school have a roster spot and a scholarship? Will I have to choose between finishing my degree and finishing my career?
Here's what colleges, accreditors and athletic associations can do.
Make athletics part of every closure plan. When a college announces a closure, its teach-out plan should include an athletics plan: which partner schools will take athletes, in which sports, with what aid, and on what timeline. Accreditors already require academic teach-outs. Athletic placement should be part of the same conversation.
Protect the season. The NCAA and NAIA should guarantee that athletes from closing schools can compete immediately at their next school, with no lost eligibility and no waiting period, and should help match them with programs that have room.
Tell recruits the truth. A college where most students are athletes should say so, along with how much it depends on athletic tuition discounts, before a 17-year-old signs. Families evaluate colleges on graduation rates and costs. They deserve to know when a school's business model is built on the roster they're joining.
Keep them in the game. Some athletes from closing colleges will transfer and keep playing. Many won't. Communities like Great Falls lose a college, but they don't have to lose the coaches, mentors and volunteers those athletes could become. Local youth programs, high schools and recreation leagues should be part of the plan, too. A former college athlete coaching a youth team in Great Falls is a return on the college's investment that outlives the college itself.
There's a temptation to treat college closures as balance-sheet events. They're not. They're hundreds of individual decisions made by students who trusted an institution with their education and their sport. Goulet's honesty is to her credit: the university believed it would be there. The athletes believed it, too.
The least higher education can do is make sure that when a college can't keep its promise, it has a plan for the people who took it at its word.
Colleges Recruited Athletes to Survive. They Owe Them a Plan When They Close.
Suggested for You
The trusted source for all job seekers
We have an extensive variety of listings for both academic and non-academic positions at postsecondary institutions.
Read More













