Welcome to The EDU Ledger.com! We’ve moved from Diverse.
Welcome to The EDU Ledger! We’ve moved from Diverse: Issues In Higher Education.

Create a free The EDU Ledger account to continue reading

College Sticker Price Is Not a Receipt

Man in brown corduroy jacket and blue jeans sitting against brick wall background

Red 'PAID IN FULL' stamp on yellow financial document with grid lines and dollar symbolsThe American Enterprise Institute recently made a startling claim: only 36 percent of Georgetown University students receive “any financial aid,” so the other 64% pay the school’s published price—“all six figures of it.” The essay, by Preston Cooper, concludes that “‘Nobody pays the sticker price’ is a fiction we can no longer afford to tell aspiring college students.” The percentage comes straight from federal data. The interpretation is completely wrong.

It’s true that college pricing can be opaque, and families deserve to know what they will owe before they apply, not after. But the essay does not show what it claims. I am a data scientist who studies injustice, so I downloaded the essay’s chart and the federal data beneath it.

Imagine a supermarket reports that 36% of shoppers used a coupon. It is correct to conclude that 64% did not. It is not correct to conclude that everyone else paid the same total: some bought smaller baskets or used other assistance the tally missed. Nor can you add rent and bus fare—costs the store never rings up—to anyone’s grocery bill. A coupon count identifies one kind of discount, not a stack of receipts.

That supermarket report is the essay’s method. The coupon is grant aid: federal data show that 36 percent of Georgetown’s degree-seeking undergraduates received grant or scholarship aid, averaging $46,250 among recipients. The essay, though, calls this “any financial aid,” and it is not. The tally leaves out student loans and veterans’ benefits—loans finance a price rather than discount it, but they are financial aid all the same. Where the federal data do measure any aid, for the narrower group of full-time, first-time students, the figure is 44%, not 36%. And the baskets differ too: the 36% counts all degree-seeking undergraduates, part-time students included, while the chart prices every school at its full-time tuition.

From there, the essay’s chart subtracts the coupon tally from 100 and labels the remainder “Share of Students Paying Sticker Price.” I reproduced that subtraction across all 1,183 colleges in the chart. The arithmetic works perfectly. But it establishes only that those students had no recorded grant—not that they received no aid, much less that they all paid the same amount. That includes the essay’s most sweeping figure—that 42% of students at the “priciest decile” of colleges pay full freight. It, too, counts missing coupons, not payments.

And the rent and bus fare? For its Georgetown headline, the essay pairs that mislabeled 2023–24 percentage with the university’s $100,864 cost-of-attendance budget for 2026–27. That six-figure number is not a single amount Georgetown charges. It is a planning estimate that adds housing, food, books, and travel to tuition and fees. Those are real costs, but they are not all charges paid to Georgetown, and they vary by circumstance. The same page, for example, lists $87,740 for a student living with parents. Nothing in the chart’s federal inputs records any family’s actual bill or payment. A budget is not a bill, and a coupon count is not a receipt.

None of this means that nobody pays sticker price. Some families do. The question the essay never asks is who they are.

The trusted source for all job seekers
We have an extensive variety of listings for both academic and non-academic positions at postsecondary institutions.
Read More
The trusted source for all job seekers