Public confidence in American higher education has fallen dramatically over the past decade, dropping from 57% in 2015 to just 36% in 2024, according to a new report from Gallup and Lumina Foundation. But the students and graduates living that experience tell a strikingly different story.
File photo
The College Reality Check: What Students Experience vs. What America Believes, released this month as part of the Lumina-Gallup 2026 State of Higher Education study, draws on responses from nearly 4,000 currently enrolled associate and bachelor's degree students and nearly 6,000 college graduates. The findings suggest that the loudest criticisms driving public doubt — campus politicization, poor career preparation and unaffordable tuition — do not match what most students report experiencing.
"While these concerns are leading skeptics of higher education to question the value of a degree or the intentions of the institutions awarding them, currently enrolled college students report markedly different experiences," the authors write.
Among the 23% of Americans who express little or no confidence in higher education, the top concern is campus politicization, with 38% of skeptics citing indoctrination or universities pushing ideological agendas — a figure that jumped 10 percentage points over 2024. Yet when researchers asked students directly, political grievances barely registered.
Between 64% and 74% of Democratic, Republican and independent students alike said all or most of their professors encourage open dialogue and support all voices during controversial discussions. Just 2% of all students — including only 3% of Republicans — said they felt they did not belong on campus because of their political views.
Sixty-nine percent of students overall said they feel a sense of belonging on their campus, a figure that held relatively steady across gender, race and party lines.
The second most cited reason for skepticism is that colleges fail to teach job-relevant skills. Here again, students push back on that narrative. Roughly nine in 10 currently enrolled students — 93% — said they are confident their coursework is teaching them career-relevant skills. Eighty-eight percent said they believe their degree will help them secure employment after graduation.
Graduates confirm those expectations largely come to fruition. Three-quarters of alumni said their degree has been "critical" or "important" to their career success. Among those who earned a bachelor's degree within the past decade, 80% said they obtained a good job within one year of graduation, with 42% reporting a position was waiting for them immediately upon completing their degree. Among recent associate degree graduates, 62% secured a good job within a year.
Where students do align with public skeptics is on the question of price. While 93% of students said they believe a community college degree is at least somewhat affordable, confidence collapsed when students assessed four-year institutions. Only 30% described private, not-for-profit universities as very or somewhat affordable. Just over half of students said four-year colleges do not charge fair prices — yet even amid those concerns, the vast majority said a degree is still worth it.
Nine in 10 bachelor's degree students (93%) and associate degree students (89%) said the overall investment they are making in college is worthwhile. About three-quarters of current students and graduates agreed that their degree is — or has been — worth the cost. That number climbs with age: 84% of graduates 60 and older said their degree was worth what they paid, compared to 65% of those between 18 and 25.
The report's authors are careful not to dismiss the persistence of real challenges on campuses. One in 10 students still lacks a meaningful sense of belonging. One in five graduates does not land a good job within a year of earning their degree. And the cost of a college education, particularly at four-year institutions, remains a barrier that the data does not minimize.
Still, the report concludes that negative individual experiences — while genuinely harmful to those who live them — may be shaping public perception in ways that outpace their prevalence. Colleges and universities, the authors argue, have both an opportunity and an obligation to tell the fuller story.
Public confidence in higher education edged back up to 42% in 2025, following years of decline. Whether that recovery holds may depend, in part, on how well institutions bridge the gap between the campus experience and what the rest of America believes is happening there.
