El Paso, TX — Hopwood — the case that has thrown affirmative action programs into a tailspin — may be a “blessing in disguise,” according to University of Texas at El Paso president Diana Natalicio.
That is because it has triggered what she calls a long-overdue review of the use of standardized testing in college admissions. In Hopwood v. State of Texas, the 5th U.S. Circuit Court ruled that race could not be used as a factor in deciding whether to admit a student. Hopwood concerned four white students who had been denied access to the University of Texas law school despite the fact that their “Texas index” scores — a combination of standardized test scores and grade point averages — were a few points higher than Mexican-American students who had been admitted. Currently, 28 percent of UT’s 48,000 students are minorities..
Last month the Supreme Court said it would not review the circuit court’s ruling. In an explanation of its decision, Supreme Court justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg said that the admissions process at the law school was a moot point since it had been changed before the court case was brought.
However, that leaves Hopwood as the binding case law in the states that make up the 5th circuit — Texas, Mississippi and Louisiana. Other states have already begun to bring their affirmative action policies into line as well, even though the ruling does not officially affect them. Speaking in El Paso before a joint meeting of the UT System Alliance for Minority Participation Academic Leadership Council and Evaluation Task Force, Natalicio said that Hopwood forces universities to reexamine their reliance on standardized tests.
